This was a hell of a week to get back into this habit due to sheer bulk.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer #20 - Shockingly high quality book of the week right here, not because it was excellent but because it was acceptable. This is only shocking of course if you realize it was written by Jeph Loeb, the master of payoff after payoff after payoff. Well, the dialogue isn't quite up to par here, but the majority of the story is a semi-flashback dream in a very cute cartoon style. The upshot of most of it being a dream is that nothing of note happens, so there's nothing to pay off really. It's a reasonably enjoyable, fun little story that serves essentially no purpose other than Joss letting Jeph write an issue. On the other hand, that means it's utterly disposable and skippable. Not Recommended for non-completionists. (If I'm honest, the biggest reason I bothered to buy it is that my mother reads the Buffyverse comics too)
Angel: After the Fall #15 - Not quite as disposable as the Buffy issue. Not at all honestly, as most of the plot threads from the very beginning of the run get tied up. I'm still not a fan of the art, as there were a number of spots where I had to make educated guesses as to the identity of the characters rather than actually being able to tell. As a fan of the series, I was astonished by my reaction to the ending, though considering this is a Joss Whedon work I won't suggest that it surprised me. Recommended for any of you who were keeping up. Don't jump ship is what I'm saying I suppose.
Uncanny X-Men #505 - This seems an unpopular opinion for whatever reason, but I rather like the Dodsons' art. It seems to draw some unfair comparisons to Frank Cho's bootylicious funtime art, which could explain it, but honestly the things that infuriate me about Cho don't typically apply here. I don't think anybody wishes the other regular penciller for the series was on though, so there's that. As much as I like Ed Brubaker, this issue just cements in my mind that he was not a good fit here, and I'm honestly glad to see him go. It'll give him more time for things he's better with, and there's no lack of those works. I can't say I'm that interested in Piotr's story here as it seems a bit unlikely as an outlet for his grief, but the rest is pretty spot on. Emma's story here definitely helps out with the Dark Reign one shot from last week, as her inclusion with the Illuminaughty (it's a Fraction book, I'll coopt his word) feels better after this issue. Recommended.
X-Men Legacy #219 - I dropped the book during Original Sin as I prefered a gap in collection to picking up bits of Daniel Way's Wolverine Origins, but fortunately it doesn't seem to matter yet. Unfortunately, this issue wasn't particularly good. A reunion with Juggernaut after the accident was inevitable at some point, but for a series that essentially set out to be making Charles into less of an asshole, this is making him into a bit of an asshole. It also retconned Juggernaut back to his earlier status quo, which may or may not be a good thing. I honestly never read any of the reformed Cain books, but don't expect any more of them anytime soon. Briones' art was servicable but uninspiring. Not Recommended.
X-Factor #38 - I dropped this book for a while too, thanks to Larry Stroman 's approximation of "art," and I'm sad to say he was back for four pages (including a two page spread) in this issue. Worse still, the rest of the issue is by Nelson (one name only) and he's not exactly my new favorite, but he's definitely far, far better. Of course, someone should probably tell him how many fingers Longshot has if both the penciller and character are going to stick around long term (hint: it's not five per hand), and while we're at it the cover had Madrox with an unmarred face. In terms of the plot, frankly it could probably have been done with another five pages or so in the last issue, and as such winds up feeling a bit superfluous. Early indications are that the next issue is one of Peter David's best works ever, so I'm not about to jump ship, but this issue itself is Not Recommended.
Robin #181 - Anarky has got to be one of the wordiest damn villains in history, and it's not amusing enough to make up for it. I don't really buy that Steph was told by Batman to become Zoom either, so that story continuing onward does nothing for me. Freddie Williams's pencils are serviceable enough. The series ends next issue, but this didn't really feel like it advanced a whole hell of a lot of the arc's plot threads. With only one issue left I'm not jumping ship now, but it's Not Recommended to jump in now.
Batman and the Outsiders #14 - Ugh. The art is pretty striking in the first few pages as it's all done very well in a widescreen style with some stark shadows and the integration of the credits into the pages like on ASS, but really the shadows were just hiding the overly hatched mess that all the later faces would turn out to be. Moreover, the major story itself is utterly idiotic and hinges on you having read the terrible Batgirl miniseries penned by the man that made Cass radioactive in the first place. Dick is an utter idiot here, Cass snipes a bit too much, and frankly the only redeeming factor is Riddler being his own egotistical ass self. Not Recommended.
Supergirl #36 - Kara flies off in half cocked rage once again, but unlike the beginning of the series she has a damn good reason. The last issue of Supergirl in New Krypton was a bit irrelevant to the overall narrative, acting more like a tie-in than chapter of the story, but don't be fooled this time. We pick up right where the last issue left off with Metallo and Reactron's rampage, and things reach their expected end, rather than a 'comic book' conclusion. We get some more time with Nightwing and Flamebird, and separately some time with Superwoman, but not enough to confirm who anyone is. I think we can safely rule Alura, the enormous bitch, out of the running as Superwoman, but stranger things have happened. Jamal Igle's pencils are good as usual, though his rendering of Kara's costume doesn't quite mesh with the last issue. All in all, an enjoyable reading experience. Recommended.
Mighty Avengers #20 - The book was split among three pencillers and inkers, but only two significant sections, which didn't really serve the issue particularly well. The flashback being in a different style from what came later I'll accept, but the rest of the story is a mixture for no good reason. After the flashback, nobody is wearing a costume, and there are more than a couple of blonde women, which makes it very difficult to tell the characters apart, and neither of the present day artists were helping that any. Bendis definitely went out on a very strong issue himself though, as everyone is well handled in an extremely troubling situation. It's not hard to understand Hank's reaction throughout the book, given the world he returned to and what he missed. This is a changing of the guard of sorts, more setting you up for Bendis' new book than the continuing adventures of the current one, but you can hardly blame him for that. All in all, Highly Recommended.
Invincible Iron Man #8 - The first arc of this book largely made me hate Marvel for being close enough to canning The Order that Fraction felt he should do so himself on his own terms, as it was an extension of that arc without any of the new characters, but since last issue it's taken a turn for the better. A ludicrously stupid and common myth about the brain aside, this book delivers some good writing and promises a hell of an upcoming story. Too bad Salvadore Larroca is such an irritating artist to match up with it. Individual panels are pretty decent, but hair styles and facial features change too much from panel to panel, including Pepper's hair getting pulled back and then let down with her glasses disappearing and reappearing on the same page while lying down. At least the characters don't all look blatantly like real actors this time. Either way, it's not bad art per se, just somewhat distracting from an otherwise excellent book. Highly Recommended.
Amazing Spider-Man #581 - I never read Death of a Goblin, so I'm not personally bothered by the Brand New Day retcon of it, and in this issue we finally get an answer as to how it happened. The answer, as it happens, is stunningly plausible for a Dan Slott book, and it deals with the consequences rather realistically. Peter was out of costume the whole time too, as a nice change of pace. I'm still in a bit of shock about this since I reacted (not on this blog) with such bile to OMN/BND, but this book is Recommended.
Thor God-Size - The issue opens with a condensed retelling of Walter Simonson's Thor #362 (reprinted in back), and then continues into a modern day extension of it. The writing is pretty much what we've come to expect from Fraction's modern myth style of Thor writing, which is to say pretty good. The art is fantastic throughout, mostly in a painted style but with a section by the Allreds that is not unwelcome. It doesn't really fit in with the current JMS run in any particular way, but since when was mythology required to fit together in tight continuity. Highly Recommended.
Dark Reign: New Nation - Did you read Secret Invasion #8 through to the back cover? Congratulations, you've read most of the first three stories here! There are a couple more pages each, though odds are they'll all be in the respective #1s for their ongoings anyway. Even worse, Marvel deigned to charge $4 for this book. This is actually more offensive than the 16pp story/16pp script abominations Ellis was shitting out and they were charging $4 for, since it's basically an advertisement for their new books on top of at least nine pages of it being in a book that nobody who cared enough to pick this up didn't already read. Stay The Fuck Away, And Screw You Marvel.
X-Men: Kingbreaker #1 - I forgot almost everything about how Emperor Vulcan ended, but this reminded me pretty darn quickly without beating me over the head with a thinly veiled recap dialogue. I'm not entirely sure why Earth based heroes that aren't already there are going to be involved with the overall War of Kings story, but the issues Vulcan is causing the rest of the universe are pretty well defined. I look forward to Gabe getting his comeuppance, which is probably the most anyone can ask for from the beginning of a story. Mildly Recommended.